Penalty Box Catering Menu & Prices

Pizza packages, wings, burger and chicken sandwich meals, appetizer trays, salads and desserts for office lunches, team meals and parties in East Alton, Alton and Wood River.

Download menu (PDF)

Submit a request to confirm availability, timing, delivery and any event-space terms. A request is not a confirmed order or booking.

Pizza Packages

Pizza Party Pack

2 cheese, 1 pepperoni, 1 sausage and 1 specialty pizza.

Package$99.99

Specialty Team Pizza Pack

3 specialty pizzas, half pan house salad and 20 breadsticks.

Package$109.99

Upgrade to a full pan of Parmesan Penalty Knots +$10.

Team Pizza Pack

5 XL one-topping pizzas, full pan house salad and 40 breadsticks.

Package$169.99

Additional toppings +$2.50 each per pizza.

Upgrade to a full pan of Parmesan Penalty Knots +$10.

Burgers & Chicken Sandwiches

Burger & Chicken Sandwich Meals

Choice of Classic Burger or Chicken Sandwich. Includes fries.

10 meals$99.99
20 meals$189.99
30 meals$279.99

Wings

Traditional Bone-In Wings

25 wings$34.99
50 wings$69.99
100 wings$139.99

Boneless Wings

Flavors: Buffalo, Lemon Pepper, Cajun Rub, Hot Honey Rub, Buffalo Blitz, Sweet Chili, BBQ, Caribbean Jerk, Carolina Gold, Flaming Honey Hot and Garlic Parmesan.

Half pan (approx. 5 lb)$69.99
Full pan (approx. 10 lb)$129.99

Dipping sauces: Ranch, Honey Mustard and Bleu Cheese.

Loaded Boneless: queso, shredded cheddar, bacon bits and green onion. Optional ranch drizzle or Buffalo drizzle. Half pan +$12.99; full pan +$24.99.

Appetizers

Mozzarella Sticks

Half pan$44.99
Full pan$84.99

Toasted Ravioli

Half pan$44.99
Full pan$84.99

Mac & Cheese Bites

Half pan$44.99
Full pan$84.99

Onion Rings

Half pan$44.99
Full pan$84.99

Dill Pickle Spears

Half pan$44.99
Full pan$84.99

Spicy Cheese Curds

Half pan$49.99
Full pan$89.99

Buffalo Egg Rolls

Half pan$49.99
Full pan$89.99

Parmesan Penalty Knots

Half pan$24.99
Full pan$49.99

Mozzarella Sticks, Toasted Ravioli and Parmesan Penalty Knots served with marinara. All other appetizers served with ranch.

Pizza

XL Cheese Pizza (16-inch)

Toppings: Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Hamburger, Chicken, White Onion, Red Onion, Green Pepper, Pineapple, Mushrooms, Pepper Rings, Black Olives, Green Olives, Jalapeños, Tomato, Extra Mozzarella and Hot Honey Drizzle.

Each$17.99

Additional toppings +$2.50 each per pizza.

Specialty Pizzas (14-inch)

BBQ Chicken, Bacon Blue, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Philly Cheesesteak, Philly Chicken, Mac & Cheese and Sweet & Sour Chicken.

Each$22.99

Salads, Sides & Desserts

House Salad

Iceberg lettuce, cheddar cheese, tomato, red onion and croutons.

Half pan$24.99
Full pan$44.99

Dressings: Ranch, Golden Italian, Thousand Island and Bleu Cheese.

Breadsticks

20 breadsticks$19.99
40 breadsticks$39.99
60 breadsticks$59.99

Cinnamon Bites

Half pan$24.99
Full pan$49.99

Food + event space in East Alton

Plan bridal and baby showers, bachelor and bachelorette parties, birthdays, team banquets or office gatherings. Penalty Box has 274 total venue seats, a patio seating 100+ and a private indoor area seating 50. Sections can be combined; layout and availability are confirmed for your date.

Catering prices cover the listed food. Venue charges and booking terms are confirmed separately.

Locations

Where Penalty Box serves

East Alton / Wood River / Alton area

Request Catering

Get Penalty Box on your next event

Catering Request — Penalty Box

More Catering Options

Joe's Pizza & Pasta

Pizza, pasta, wings and salads for groups, from Edwardsville, Godfrey, Jerseyville and Mascoutah.

Clubhouse Lounge + Kitchen

Sliders, wings, platters and buffets, plus a private room and patio in Edwardsville.

Penalty Box Bar & Grill Catering